| American League | National League | |||||||
| MVP | Cy Young | Rookie | Manager | MVP | Cy Young | Rookie | Manager | |
| Beth | Mike Trout | Jered Weaver | Dylan Bundy | John Gibbons | Joey Votto | Clayton Kershaw | Oscar Taveras | Mike Matheny |
| Chad | Josh Hamilton | Chris Sale | Wil Myers | Buck Showalter | Matt Kemp | Stephen Strasburg | Oscar Taveras | Don Mattingly |
| Dan | Mike Trout | Justin Verlander | Jurickson Profar | Mike Scioscia | Bryce Harper | Stephen Strasburg | Travis d'Arnaud | Davey Johnson |
| Darcy | Mike Trout | Justin Verlander | Wil Myers | Joe Madden | Andrew McCutchen | Clayton Kershaw | Travis d'Arnaud | Mike Matheny |
| Dave | Mike Trout | James Shields | Aaron Hicks | Mike Scioscia | Jason Heyward | Gio Gonzalez | Matt Harvey | Freddy Gonzalez |
| Derry | Evan Longoria | Chris Sale | Dylan Bundy | Joe Madden | Bryce Harper | Clayton Kershaw | Adam Eaton | Davey Johnson |
| Dustin | Robinson Cano | David Price | Trevor Bauer | Terry Francona | Joey Votto | Matt Cain | Travis d'Arnaud | Davey Johnson |
| Jean | Evan Longoria | Justin Verlander | Dylan Bundy | Joe Madden | Jason Heyward | Zach Greinke | Adam Eaton | Freddy Gonzalez |
| Landon | Miguel Cabrera | Justin Verlander | Wil Myers | John Gibbons | Yadier Molina | Clayton Kershaw | Gerrit Cole | Don Mattingly |
| Stefan | Albert Pujols | Justin Verlander | Bruce Rondon | Mike Scioscia | Stephen Strasburg | Stephen Strasburg | Adam Eaton | Mike Matheny |
| Sulli | Robinson Cano | David Price | Bruce Rondon | Ned Yost | Matt Kemp | Kris Medlen | Tyler Skaggs | Bruce Bochy |
| Twaddle | Miguel Cabrera | Yu Darvish | Jurickson Profar | Robin Ventura | Matt Kemp | Clayton Kershaw | Tyler Skaggs | Kirk Gibson |
| American League | National League | |||||||||
| West | Central | East | Wildcard | West | Central | East | Wildcard | |||
| Beth | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Rangers over Yankees | Giants | Cardinals | Nationals | Dodgers over Reds | ||
| Chad | Angels | Tigers | Orioles | Rays over Rangers | Dodgers | Cardinals | Braves | Nationals over Reds | ||
| Dan | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Indians over A's | Dodgers | Reds | Nationals | Giants over Cardinals | ||
| Darcy | Angels | Tigers | Rays | Blue Jays over A's | Giants | Cardinals | Nationals | Reds over Braves | ||
| Dave | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Royals over A's | Giants | Reds | Braves | Nationals over Dodgers | ||
| Derry | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Rays over Rangers | Giants | Reds | Nationals | Cardinals over Braves | ||
| Dustin | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Rays over Indians | Dodgers | Cardinals | Nationals | Reds over Braves | ||
| Jean | A's | Tigers | Rays | Blue Jays over Mariners | Dodgers | Reds | Braves | Giants over Cardinals | ||
| Landon | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | A's over Indians | Giants | Reds | Nationals | Dodgers over Braves | ||
| Stefan | Angels | Tigers | Blue Jays | Rangers over Yankees | Dodgers | Cardinals | Nationals | Giants over Reds | ||
| Sulli | Rangers | Royals | Rays | Orioles over Angels | Giants | Cardinals | Nationals | Dodgers over Reds | ||
| Twaddle | Rangers | White Sox | Blue Jays | Tigers over Rays | Dodgers | Reds | Nationals | Diamondbacks over Pirates | ||
| ALCS | NLCS | World Series | # of games | ||||
| Beth | Angels over Blue Jays | Nationals over Cardinals | Angels over Nationals | 6 games | |||
| Chad | Angels over Orioles | Dodgers over Cardinals | Dodgers over Angels | 6 games | |||
| Dan | Angels over Blue Jays | Nationals over Reds | Nationals over Angels | 6 games | |||
| Darcy | Angels over Rays | Cardinals over Nationals | Cardinals over Angels | 6 games | |||
| Dave | Angels over Blue Jays | Braves over Nationals | Braves over Angels | 7 games | |||
| Derry | Rays over Blue Jays | Nationals over Cardinals | Nationals over Rays | 6 games | |||
| Dustin | Rays over Angels | Nationals over Cardinals | Nationals over Rays | 6 games | |||
| Jean | Rays over Tigers | Braves over Dodgers | Braves over Rays | 6 games | |||
| Landon | Blue Jays over Tigers | Nationals over Dodgers | Nationals over Blue Jays | 6 games | |||
| Stefan | Angels over Blue Jays | Cardinals over Dodgers | Cardinals over Angels | 7 games | |||
| Sulli | Rays over Rangers | Nationals over Cardinals | Nationals over Rays | 5 games | |||
| Twaddle | Tigers over White Sox | Nationals over Diamondbacks | Nationals over Tigers | 5 games | |||